American University
Browse

The Hold-up Problem in Colombian Contract Law

Version 2 2025-04-03, 17:30
Version 1 2023-08-04, 15:56
thesis
posted on 2023-08-04, 15:56 authored by Juan Antonio Gaviria

As its title suggests, this dissertation studies the interaction between an economic issue (the hold-up problem) and a legal system (Colombian law). For this purpose, this dissertation first defines the hold-up problem and explains its causes and possible solutions. The dissertation then analyzes how U.S. and Colombian laws deal with the hold-up problem and with its main harmful effect: the reduction of idiosyncratic investments. The U.S. law is studied here not only to facilitate the comparison of a civil law country's approach to the hold-up problem (Colombia) with the perspective of a common law country (the United States) but also to inquire whether some of the solutions to the hold-up problem under the latter legal system might be successfully transplanted to the former one. The study of these legal systems delves into the role of both contractual and legal devices that may avoid, solve, or mitigate the hold-up problem (in general, that may prevent it). The contractual devices discussed here are no modification clauses, stipulated damages clauses, and reputation bonds. The legal devices, in turn, are legal rules entitling courts either to annul modifications in hold-up situations on grounds such as economic duress and bad-faith or to grant remedies for breach of contract. This theoretical analysis is coupled with an experiment with Colombian students testing the theories stating that penalty clauses (on one hand) and a high level of legal remedies for breach of contract (on the other) may prevent the hold-up problem. The results of this experiment failed to confirm the predictions of the theory. Based on the findings of the theoretical and experimental chapters, and before making some concluding remarks, the dissertation presents some proposals to efficiently address the hold-up problem in Colombian contract law.

History

Publisher

ProQuest

Language

English

Handle

http://hdl.handle.net/1961/16559

Committee chair

David V. Snyder

Committee member(s)

Jonathan Baker; Kathryn Zeiler

Degree discipline

Judicial Science

Degree grantor

Washington College of Law. American University

Degree level

  • Doctoral

Degree name

S.J.D. Washington College of Law, American University, 2014

Local identifier

thesesdissertations_296_0001_OBJ.pdf

Media type

application/pdf

Pagination

295 pages

Call number

Thesis 10056

MMS ID

99147120253604102

Submission ID

10577

Usage metrics

    Theses and Dissertations

    Exports

    RefWorks
    BibTeX
    Ref. manager
    Endnote
    DataCite
    NLM
    DC